Comparing costs and fee transparency: do we have it right?

In 2019, the Australian Government launched Medical Costs Finder, an online comparison tool for consumers to understand and compare the average cost of specialist medical services. In the recent 2020-21 Federal Budget, another $17 million was committed to its ongoing development, which has prompted us to explore the website’s effectiveness and its role as a solution to fee transparency.

Financial transparency in healthcare is a growing consideration for Australian consumers and an important topic for the sustainability of our current dual health system.

However, the most effective way to ensure patients are given the right information about fee transparency remains a point of contention.

A work in progress

The current Medical Costs Finder website displays at least 62* common in- and out-of-hospital procedures and treatments and compares these with the patient’s surrounding areas. The ‘typical’ or median amounts for doctors’ fees, Medicare benefits, health fund benefits and patient out-of-pocket costs are provided for each procedure or treatment.1 The website does not include hospital costs such as accommodation, theatre or medical devices.

The recent budget allocation is proposed to support upgrades to the website to display fees of individual specialists. Importantly, it is proposed that doctors voluntarily opt-in to the system and allow their data to be available to the general public.

At a recent Senate address, Professor Brendan Murphy confirmed that while the $17 million budget allocation stands, the addition of individual specialist fees and any further developments into the website will be delayed until at least the end of 2021 because of COVID-19.2

Opinions remain divided

In view of the significant investment made into the website, some have questioned whether it is the best tool to provide information on medical costs or to address fee transparency.

The Australian Medical Association (AMA) and Australian Patients Association (APA) have made it clear that they are strong advocates for healthcare costs transparency, yet they have questioned whether the Medical Costs Finder is the right avenue for delivery and whether it will achieve its stated goals.

Both the AMA and APA have expressed doubt that doctors would voluntarily agree to publish their fees, and that a website without complete information doesn’t assist the patient or the medical practitioner.3 The proposed opt-in approach wouldn’t allow patients to confidently understand their fees and compare these against other practitioners who provide the same services.

The AMA has made calls for an impartial and complete resource from the beginning. One that covers health literacy, the role of health insurance, advice on hospital fees, and tools to ask specialists the right questions. They also highlight the importance of the right doctor for the individual circumstances, and “informed financial consent”.

Others have recognised the potential and see the benefits of the Medical Costs Finder.

Peak industry body Members’ Health Fund Alliance have called the recent budget announcement an “important step” towards improving fee transparency.4,5 They also believe the tool will be especially useful for general practitioners when they are referring patients.

Professor Charlotte Hespe, Sydney-based GP and Chair of RACGP NSW & ACT, agrees. She believes the tool is a great initiative and will be useful for GPs when referring patients to specialists. Although she does have reservations around the website’s accuracy and the ability for patients to properly navigate the tool without having the same level of health literacy as doctors.

Still not hitting the mark?

Ongoing funding by the Australian Government suggests their Medical Costs Finder is here to stay.

Early opinions about the website leaves us questioning whether we will see an uptake in use or if it will have a smaller impact than intended. A lack of unity on the subject could put the effectiveness of the website at risk and prevent it from achieving its ultimate goal. To that end, it has certainly started a conversation.


*Information current as of December 2019 – smh.com.au/healthcare/doctors-fee-transparency-website-goes-live-but-fails-to-list-who-charges-what-20191230-p53no4.html. The Australian Government have stated they will continue to add more services over time. However, the specifics of when and how many, is unknown.

1 Australian Government Department of Health
2 smh.com.au/politics/federal/specialist-fee-transparency-website-put-on-ice-due-to-pandemic-20201026-p568uc.html
3 theage.com.au/politics/federal/patients-the-loser-despite-17m-lift-for-white-elephant-medical-costs-website-20201009-p563mu.html
4 membershealth.com.au/budget-delivers-big-wins-for-australian-consumers
5 AMA Prescription for Private Health Insurance, 17 August 2020

Read next

Article 1 of 6